WASHINGTON, Jan. 17 — The Congressional Analysis Service issued the next report (No. R45242) on Jan. 9, 2023, entitled “Non-public Flood Insurance coverage and the Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program” by Diane P. Horn, flood Insurance coverage and emergency administration specialist, and Baird Webel, appearing part analysis supervisor.
Listed here are excerpts:
* * *
Abstract
The Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program (NFIP) is the principle supply of main flood insurance coverage protection in america, gathering over $4.6 billion in premiums, charges, and surcharges for over 5 million flood insurance coverage insurance policies. That is in distinction to the vast majority of different property and casualty dangers, reminiscent of injury from fireplace or accidents, that are lined by a broad array of personal insurance coverage corporations. One of many main causes behind the creation of the NFIP in 1968 was the withdrawal by non-public insurers from offering flood insurance coverage protection, leaving flood victims largely reliant on federal catastrophe help to get better after a flood. Whereas non-public insurers have taken on comparatively little flood danger, they’ve been concerned within the administration of the NFIP by gross sales and servicing of insurance policies and claims.
In recent times, non-public insurers have expressed elevated curiosity in offering flood protection. Advances within the analytics and knowledge used to quantify flood danger together with will increase in capital market capacities might permit non-public insurers to tackle flood dangers that they shunned previously. Non-public flood insurance coverage might supply some benefits over the NFIP, together with extra versatile flood polices, built-in protection with owners insurance coverage, or lower-cost protection for some customers. Non-public advertising may also improve the general quantity of flood protection bought, decreasing the quantity of extraordinary catastrophe help essential to be offered by the federal authorities. Elevated non-public protection might cut back the general monetary danger to the NFIP, decreasing the quantity of NFIP borrowing essential after main disasters.
Rising non-public insurance coverage, nevertheless, might have some downsides in comparison with the NFIP. Non-public protection wouldn’t be assured to be obtainable to all floodplain residents, not like the NFIP, and client protections might differ in numerous states. The function of the NFIP has traditionally been broader than simply offering insurance coverage. As at the moment licensed, the NFIP additionally encompasses social objectives to offer flood insurance coverage in flood-prone areas to property homeowners who in any other case wouldn’t have the ability to get hold of it, and to cut back authorities’s value after floods. By means of flood mapping and mitigation efforts, the NFIP has tried to cut back the longer term affect of floods, and it’s unclear how successfully the NFIP might play this broader function if non-public insurance coverage turned a big a part of the flood market. Elevated non-public insurance coverage might additionally have an effect on the subsidies which are offered for some customers by the NFIP.
The 2012 reauthorization of the NFIP (Division F, Title II of P.L. 112-141) included provisions encouraging non-public flood insurance coverage; nevertheless, numerous limitations have remained. Laws handed the Home within the 114th Congress (H.R. 2901) and a hundred and fifteenth Congress (H.R. 2874) which might have tried to increase the function of personal flood insurance coverage; neither invoice was taken up by the Senate. Within the 116th Congress, no NFIP laws superior previous introduction. Two payments have been launched within the 117th Congress for long-term reauthorization and reform of the NFIP.
The NFIP is at the moment working underneath a short-term reauthorization till September 30, 2023.
* * *
Contents
Introduction … 1
Background … 1
Goals of the NFIP … 2
Major Flood Insurance coverage By means of the NFIP … 3
The Obligatory Buy Requirement … 3
Premium Subsidies and Cross-Subsidies … 4
NFIP Reauthorization and Laws … 5
117th Congress … 5
Prior Congresses … 5
The Present Position of Non-public Insurers within the NFIP … 6
Servicing of Insurance policies and Claims Administration … 6
Reinsurance … 8 Non-public Flood Insurance coverage Outdoors the NFIP: Points and Limitations … 10
Flood Insurance coverage Protection “at Least as Broad as” the NFIP … 11
Steady Protection … 12
The “Non-Compete” Clause … 12
NFIP Backed Charges … 13
Regulatory Uncertainty … 15
Capacity to Assess Flood Threat Precisely … 15
Ample Shopper Participation … 16
Potential Results of Elevated Non-public Sector Involvement within the Flood Market … 17
Elevated Shopper Alternative … 17
Cheaper Flood Insurance coverage … 17
Variable Shopper Protections … 18
Hostile Choice … 18
Points for NFIP Flood Mapping and Floodplain Administration … 19
Concluding Feedback … 20
Tables
Desk 1. NFIP Reinsurance Purchases … 9
Desk A-1. Provisions Associated to Non-public Flood Insurance coverage in Laws within the 116th Congress … 25
Appendixes
Appendix. Provisions Associated to Non-public Flood Insurance coverage in Laws within the 116th Congress … 22
Contacts
Writer Data … 27
* * *
Introduction
Congress is at the moment contemplating long-term reauthorization of the Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program (NFIP). Floods are the commonest pure catastrophe in america, and all 50 states, plus DC, Puerto Rico, Guam, American Samoa, the U.S. Virgin Islands, and the Northern Mariana Islands have skilled flood occasions since Might 2018./1
The NFIP has paid a complete of practically $19.03 billion in claims over the previous 5 fiscal years./2
Increasing the function of personal insurers, together with reinsurers, has been seen by many as a solution to the variability of the monetary place of the NFIP./3
Rising participation by non-public insurers might switch extra flood danger from policyholders to the non-public insurance coverage sector, versus transferring the chance to the federal authorities by the NFIP. Along with the attainable benefit to the NFIP, the elevated availability of flood insurance coverage as non-public corporations enter the market might profit households and companies, as insured flood victims are prone to get better extra rapidly and extra absolutely after a flood.
Non-public insurer curiosity in instantly offering and underwriting flood danger has elevated lately. Advances within the analytics and knowledge used to quantify flood danger together with will increase in capital market capacities might permit non-public insurers to tackle flood dangers that they shunned previously. Nonetheless, growing the non-public sector function in offering flood insurance coverage protection on to customers might have implications for the operations and monetary solvency of the NFIP as at the moment structured. Elevated entry to non-public flood insurance coverage might present particular person policyholders with a wider selection of protection and presumably cheaper premiums, however can also result in variable client protections.
The extent to which non-public insurance coverage corporations take part within the U.S. flood insurance coverage market represents an space of congressional concern. Numerous payments have been launched to handle points associated to non-public flood insurance coverage, however no laws has but been enacted. The NFIP is at the moment working underneath its twenty fifth short-term reauthorization, till September 30, 2023./4
This report describes the present function of personal insurers in U.S. flood insurance coverage, and discusses limitations to non-public sector involvement. The report considers potential results of elevated non-public sector involvement within the U.S. flood market, each for the NFIP and for customers. Lastly, the report outlines the provisions related to non-public flood insurance coverage in Home and Senate NFIP reauthorization payments from the a hundred and fifteenth, 116th, and 117th Congresses.
Background/5
The NFIP is the principle supplier of main flood insurance coverage protection for residential properties in america, offering practically $1.3 trillion in protection for over 5 million residential flood insurance coverage insurance policies. In FY2018, this system collected about $3.51 billion in annual premium income, $1.09 billion in assessments, charges, and surcharges and $1.04 billion in funds from non-public reinsurers./6
* * *
1 E-mail correspondence from FEMA Congressional Affairs employees, August 5, 2019.
2 E-mail correspondence from FEMA Congressional Affairs employees, December 30, 2020.
3 FEMA, Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program Report back to Congress on Reinsuring NFIP Insurance coverage Threat and Choices for Privatizing the NFIP, August 13, 2015, p. 41.
4 P.L. 117-328. For additional info on NFIP reauthorization, see CRS Perception IN10835, What Occurs If the Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program (NFIP) Lapses?, by Diane P. Horn.
5 For extra element on the NFIP, see CRS Report R44593, Introduction to the Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program (NFIP), by Diane P. Horn and Baird Webel.
6 Statistics on the Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program (NFIP) coverage and claims can be found from the Federal Emergency Administration Company (FEMA) web site “Coverage and Declare Statistics for Flood Insurance coverage,” at https://www.fema.gov/policy-claim-statistics-flood-insurance; premium and price knowledge from The Watermark Third Quarter 2021, https://www.fema.gov/websites/default/information/paperwork/fema_fima-watermark-FY2021-Q3.pdf.
* * *
In FY2019, this system collected about $3.39 billion in annual premium income and $1.07 billion in assessments, charges, and surcharge, with no funds from non-public reinsurers./7
In FY2020, this system collected about $3.51 billion in annual premium income and $1.11 billion in assessments, charges, and surcharge, with no funds from non-public reinsurers.
Nationally, over 22,000 communities take part within the NFIP./8
The function of the federal authorities in flood insurance coverage is in distinction to the vast majority of different property and casualty dangers, reminiscent of injury from fireplace or accidents, that are lined by a broad array of personal insurance coverage corporations. Whole direct written premiums for personal flood insurance coverage in 2019 totaled $523 billion, in comparison with $420 million in 2018 and $390 million in 2017. Over 140 insurers wrote non-public flood insurance coverage in 2019, up from 120 insurers in 2018, 90 insurers in 2017, and 50 insurers in 2016./9
Whole premiums for personal property and casualty insurance coverage in 2018 totaled $611 billion, with the insurance policies backed by over $2 trillion in belongings held by non-public insurers./10
Goals of the NFIP
The NFIP has two most important coverage objectives: (1) to offer entry to main flood insurance coverage, thereby permitting for the switch of a number of the monetary danger of property homeowners to the federal authorities; and (2) to mitigate and cut back the nation’s complete flood danger/11 by the event and implementation of floodplain administration requirements. An extended-term goal of the NFIP is to cut back federal expenditure on catastrophe help after floods.
As a public insurance coverage program, the NFIP is designed otherwise from the way in which through which non-public sector corporations present insurance coverage. As at the moment licensed, the NFIP additionally encompasses social objectives to offer flood insurance coverage in flood-prone areas to property homeowners who in any other case wouldn’t have the ability to get hold of it, and to cut back the federal government’s value after floods./12
The NFIP additionally engages in lots of “non-insurance” actions within the public curiosity: it disseminates flood danger info by flood maps, requires communities to undertake land use and constructing code requirements with a purpose to take part in this system, probably reduces the necessity for different post-flood catastrophe support, contributes to neighborhood resilience by offering a mechanism to fund rebuilding after a flood, and will shield lending establishments towards mortgage defaults because of uninsured losses.
* * *
7 Price knowledge from The Watermark Third Quarter 2021, https://www.fema.gov/websites/default/information/paperwork/fema_fimawatermark-FY2021-Q3.pdf.
8 Detailed details about which communities take part and the place is on the market from the Group Standing Ebook, discovered on FEMA’s web site at https://www.fema.gov/flood-insurance/work-with-nfip/community-status-book.
9 Nationwide Affiliation of Insurance coverage Commissioners (NAIC), Report on Non-public Flood Insurance coverage Knowledge, April 28, 2020, offered by NAIC to CRS on October 24, 2020.
10 Premium quantities used are web premiums written and asset quantities are admitted belongings from A.M. Finest, 2019 Finest’s Rankings: U.S. Property/Casualty – 2018 Monetary Outcomes, March 25, 2019.
11 Within the context of this report, complete flood danger implies that the chance consists of each monetary danger (i.e., bodily injury to property), and likewise the chance to human life.
12 See 82 Stat. 573 for textual content in unique statute (Part 1302(c) of P.L. 90-448). This language stays in statute (see 42 U.S.C. Sec.4001(c)).
* * *
The advantages of such duties usually are not instantly measured within the NFIP’s monetary outcomes from promoting flood insurance coverage./13
From the inception of the NFIP, this system has been anticipated to attain a number of goals, a few of which can battle with each other:
* to make sure affordable insurance coverage premiums for all;
* to have risk-based premiums that will make individuals conscious of and bear the price of their floodplain location selections;
* to safe widespread neighborhood participation within the NFIP and substantial numbers of insurance coverage coverage purchases by property homeowners; and
* to earn premium and price earnings that, over time, covers claims paid and program bills./14
Major Flood Insurance coverage By means of the NFIP
The NFIP presents flood insurance coverage to anybody in a neighborhood that chooses to take part in this system. Flood insurance coverage buy usually is voluntary, aside from property homeowners who’re in a Particular Flood Hazard Space (SFHA)/15 and whose mortgage is backed by the federal authorities./16
Flood insurance coverage insurance policies by the NFIP are offered solely in collaborating communities and are provided to each property homeowners and renters and to residential and nonresidential properties. NFIP insurance policies have comparatively low protection limits, significantly for nonresidential properties or properties in high-cost areas. The utmost protection for single-family dwellings (which additionally consists of single-family residential models inside a 2-4 household constructing) is $100,000 for contents and as much as $250,000 for constructing protection. The utmost obtainable protection restrict for different residential buildings is $500,000 for constructing protection and $100,000 for contents protection, and the utmost protection restrict for nonresidential enterprise buildings is $500,000 for constructing protection and $500,000 for contents protection.
The Obligatory Buy Requirement
By regulation and regulation, federal businesses, federally regulated lending establishments, and government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs)/17 should require the property homeowners in an SFHA to buy flood insurance coverage as a situation of any mortgage that these entities make, assure, or buy./18
* * *
13 American Academy of Actuaries Flood Insurance coverage Work Group, The Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program: Challenges and Options, April 2017, p. 79, http://www.actuary.org/information/publications/FloodMonograph.04192017.pdf.
14 Nationwide Analysis Council of the Nationwide Academies, Affordability of Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program Premiums: Report 1, 2015, p. 3, http://www.nap.edu/catalog/21709/affordability-of-national-flood-insurance-programpremiums-report-1.
15 A Particular Flood Hazard Space (SFHA) is outlined by FEMA as an space with a 1% or higher danger of flooding yearly.
16 This consists of mortgages from banks insured by the Federal Deposit Insurance coverage Company and mortgages backed by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac, in addition to federal entities such because the Federal Housing Administration and the Division of Veterans Affairs.
17 Authorities-Sponsored Enterprises (GSEs) are non-public corporations with congressional charters. Examples of GSEs offering mortgages that will be affected by the obligatory buy requirement embrace the Federal House Mortgage Mortgage Company (Freddie Mac) and the Federal Nationwide Mortgage Affiliation (Fannie Mae).
18 42 U.S.C. Sec.4012a.
* * *
Along with this authorized obligatory buy requirement, lenders can also require debtors exterior of an SFHA to keep up flood insurance coverage as a way of financially securing the property.
So as to adjust to this mandate, property homeowners might buy flood insurance coverage by the NFIP, or by a personal firm, as long as the non-public flood insurance coverage “offers flood insurance coverage protection which is a minimum of as broad because the protection” of the NFIP, amongst different circumstances./19
The obligatory buy requirement is enforced by the lender, moderately than FEMA, and lenders will be fined as much as $2,000 by banking regulators for every failure to require flood insurance coverage or present discover./20
Property homeowners who don’t get hold of flood insurance coverage when required might discover that they aren’t eligible for sure varieties of catastrophe help after a flood./21
Premium Subsidies and Cross-Subsidies
Flood insurance coverage charges within the NFIP usually are directed by statute to be “based mostly on consideration of the chance concerned and accepted actuarial rules,”/22 which means that the speed is reflective of the true flood danger to the property. Nonetheless, Congress has directed FEMA to not cost actuarial charges for sure classes of properties and to supply reductions to different courses of properties./23
FEMA will not be, nevertheless, offered funds to offset these subsidies and reductions,/24 which has contributed to FEMA’s must borrow from the U.S. Treasury to pay NFIP claims.
There are three most important classes of properties that pay lower than full risk-based charges:
* Pre-FIRM: properties that have been constructed or considerably improved earlier than December 31, 1974, or earlier than FEMA printed the primary Flood Insurance coverage Fee Map (FIRM) for his or her neighborhood, whichever was later;/25
* Newly mapped: properties which are newly mapped right into a SFHA on or after April 1, 2015, if the applicant obtains protection that’s efficient inside 12 months of the map revision date;/26 and
* Grandfathered: properties that have been inbuilt compliance with the FIRM in impact on the time of building and are allowed to keep up their outdated flood insurance coverage charge class if their property is remapped into a brand new flood charge class./27
* * *
19 42 U.S.C Sec.4012a(b). For extra info on non-public flood insurance coverage, see CRS Perception IN10450, Non-public Flood Insurance coverage and the Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program (NFIP), by Baird Webel and Diane P. Horn. The “a minimum of as broad as” requirement is mentioned in additional element within the part titled “Flood Insurance coverage Protection “at Least as Broad as” the NFIP” on this report.
20 42 U.S.C Sec.4012a(f).
21 For extra info, see CRS Report R44808, Federal Catastrophe Help: The Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program and Different Federal Catastrophe Help Applications Out there to People and Households After a Flood, by Diane P. Horn.
22 42 U.S.C. Sec.4014(a)(1).
23 For a full dialogue of NFIP subsidies and cross-subsidies, see the part on Pricing and Premium Fee Construction in CRS Report R44593, Introduction to the Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program (NFIP), by Diane P. Horn and Baird Webel, the part on Premiums Subsidies and Cross-Subsidies in CRS Report R46095, The Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program: Chosen Points and Laws within the 116th Congress, by Diane P. Horn and Baird Webel, and the part on Premium Subsidies and Cross-Subsidies in CRS Report R45999, Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program: The Present Ranking Construction and Threat Ranking 2.0, by Diane P. Horn.
24 Authorities Accountability Workplace (GAO), Flood Insurance coverage: Complete Reform Might Enhance Solvency and Improve Resilience, GAO-17-425, April 2017, p. 17, https://www.gao.gov/merchandise/GAO-17-425.
25 42 U.S.C. Sec.4015(c).
26 Sec.6 of P.L. 113-89, 128 Stat.1028, as codified at 42 U.S.C. Sec.4015(i).
27 For a full description, see FEMA, Grandfathering, March 2020, https://www.fema.gov/node/404682.
* * *
NFIP Reauthorization and Laws
117th Congress
The NFIP is at the moment licensed till September 30, 2023./28 For the reason that finish of FY2017, 25 short-term NFIP reauthorizations have been enacted. Two companion payments have been launched within the 117th Congress for reform and reauthorization of the NFIP: S. 3128 and H.R. 5802, the Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program Reauthorization and Reform Act of 2021. These payments weren’t thought-about by the committees of jurisdiction.
Prior Congresses
The Home handed standalone laws to encourage non-public insurance coverage within the 114th Congress (H.R. 2901); nevertheless, the Senate didn’t take up H.R. 2901 within the 114th Congress.
Within the a hundred and fifteenth Congress, numerous payments have been launched to offer a longer-term reauthorization of the NFIP in addition to make quite a few different modifications to this system. The Home of
Representatives handed H.R. 2874 (The twenty first Century Flood Reform Act) by a vote of 237-189 on November 14, 2017. Amongst its quite a few provisions, H.R. 2874 would have licensed the NFIP till September 30, 2022.
Three payments have been launched within the Senate that will have reauthorized the expiring provisions of the NFIP:
* S. 1313 (Flood Insurance coverage Affordability and Sustainability Act of 2017);
* S. 1368 (Sustainable, Inexpensive, Honest, and Environment friendly [SAFE] Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program Reauthorization Act of 2017);/29 and
* S. 1571 (Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program Reauthorization Act of 2017).
None of those payments have been thought-about by the complete Senate within the a hundred and fifteenth Congress. Amongst their different provisions, S. 1313 would have licensed the NFIP till September 30, 2027; S. 1368 would have licensed the NFIP till September 30, 2023; and S. 1571 would have licensed the NFIP till September 30, 2023.
* * *
28 The statute for the NFIP doesn’t comprise a complete expiration, termination, or sundown provision for the entire of this system. Slightly, the NFIP has a number of totally different authorized provisions that usually tie to the expiration of key elements of this system. Except reauthorized or amended by Congress, the next will happen on September 30, 2023: (1) The authority to offer new flood insurance coverage contracts will expire. Flood insurance coverage contracts entered into earlier than the expiration would proceed till the tip of their coverage time period of 1 yr; and (2) The authority for NFIP to borrow funds from the Treasury shall be decreased from $30.425 billion to $1 billion (42 U.S.C. Sec.4016(a)). The newest reauthorization of the NFIP is in P.L. 117-328.
29 An analogous invoice was launched within the Home, H.R. 3285.
* * *
The 4 reauthorization payments within the a hundred and fifteenth Congress differed considerably within the diploma to which they might have inspired non-public participation in flood insurance coverage, significantly flood insurance coverage offered by non-public corporations in competitors with the NFIP. Basically, laws handed by the Home was extra encouraging of personal flood insurance coverage than Senate laws. Within the a hundred and fifteenth Congress, the Home included the identical provisions in H.R. 2874 and in an unrelated invoice to reauthorize the Federal Aviation Administration (H.R. 3823). The Senate eliminated the flood insurance coverage language from H.R. 3823 earlier than passing it. Reportedly, the provisions relating to non-public flood insurance coverage have been a specific difficulty of concern./30 The Senate finally didn’t take up H.R. 2874 in the course of the a hundred and fifteenth Congress. S. 1313 included some comparable provisions to H.R. 2874 on non-public flood insurance coverage, however S. 1368 and S. 1571 didn’t.
Within the 116th Congress, the Home Monetary Providers Committee accomplished markup of a invoice for the long-term reauthorization of the NFIP, the Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program Reauthorization Act of 2019 (H.R. 3167), and ordered it reported on June 12, 2019./31 H.R. 3167 would have reauthorized the NFIP till September 30, 2024. One invoice was launched within the Senate, on July 18, 2019, to reauthorize the expiring provisions of the NFIP: the Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program Reauthorization and Reform Act of 2019 (S. 2187), with a companion invoice within the Home, H.R. 3872./32 The latter two payments weren’t thought-about by the committees of jurisdiction. S. 2187 and H.R. 3872 would even have reauthorized the NFIP till September 30, 2024. Particulars of the provisions relating to non-public insurance coverage within the Home and Senate payments within the 116th Congress are described within the Appendix, and Desk A-1 relates the provisions within the payments within the 116th Congress to the problems mentioned on this report.
The Present Position of Non-public Insurers within the NFIP
Non-public insurers will be concerned within the flood insurance coverage market in numerous methods, together with (1) by serving to to manage the NFIP; (2) by sharing danger with the NFIP as a reinsurer; or (3) by taking over danger themselves as a main insurer, the place the insurer contracts instantly with a client. Since 1983, non-public insurers have performed a serious function in administering the NFIP, together with promoting and servicing insurance policies and adjusting claims, however they largely haven’t been underwriting flood danger themselves./33 As an alternative, the NFIP retains the direct monetary danger of paying claims for these insurance policies. The NFIP has bought reinsurance since 2016, thus transferring a number of the flood danger to the non-public sector.
* * *
30 See, for instance, Shaun Courtney, “‘Arduous to Envision’ Senate Democrats Blocking FAA Extension, Thune Says,” Bloomberg BNA, September 27, 2017, Every day Report for Executives,
Thune needs to see the Senate go the Home invoice underneath unanimous consent, however committee rating member Invoice Nelson (D-Fla.) made that sound unlikely. “That won’t get handed right here,” Nelson stated Sept. 26 in response to Bloomberg BNA’s inquiry concerning the Home’s flood insurance coverage provision…. Senator Sherrod Brown (D-Ohio), rating member on the Banking, Housing, and City Affairs Committee, which has jurisdiction over flood insurance coverage proposals, stated the Home provision was unacceptable. “We’re not going to do it,” Brown stated. “This might undermine all of our flood insurance coverage efforts. It can trigger every kind of cherry-picking by non-public insurance coverage.” 31 See H.Rept. 116-262, Half 1, https://www.congress.gov/116/crpt/hrpt262/CRPT-116hrpt262.pdf.
32 H.R. 3872 was launched on July 22, 2019.
33 Underwriting danger refers back to the potential loss to an insurer or reinsurer. An insurer takes on this danger in return for a premium, and guarantees to pay an agreed quantity within the occasion of a loss. See NAIC, Glossary of Insurance coverage Phrases, http://www.naic.org/consumer_glossary.htm#U.
* * *
Servicing of Insurance policies and Claims Administration
Whereas FEMA offers the overarching administration and oversight of the NFIP, the vast majority of the day-to-day operation of the NFIP is dealt with by non-public corporations. This consists of advertising, promoting and writing insurance policies, and all points of claims administration./34 FEMA has established two totally different preparations with non-public business. The primary is the Direct Servicing Agent, or DSA, which operates as a personal contractor, promoting NFIP insurance policies on behalf of FEMA for people searching for to buy flood insurance coverage insurance policies instantly from the NFIP./35 The DSA additionally handles the insurance policies of extreme repetitive loss properties./36 The second association is the Write-Your-Personal (WYO) program, the place non-public insurance coverage corporations are paid to difficulty and repair NFIP insurance policies.
With both the DSA or WYO program, the NFIP retains the precise monetary danger of paying claims for the coverage, and the coverage phrases and premiums are the identical. Roughly 13% of the entire NFIP coverage portfolio is managed by the DSA and 87% of NFIP insurance policies are offered by the 57 corporations collaborating within the WYO program./37
Firms collaborating within the WYO program are compensated by quite a lot of strategies, however this compensation will not be instantly based mostly on the prices incurred by the WYOs. Within the Biggert-Waters Flood Insurance coverage Reform Act of 2012 (Division F, Title II of P.L. 112-141, hereinafter BW-12), Congress required FEMA to develop and difficulty a rulemaking on a “methodology for figuring out the suitable quantities that property and casualty insurance coverage corporations collaborating within the WYO program must be reimbursed for promoting, writing, and servicing flood insurance coverage insurance policies and adjusting flood insurance coverage claims on behalf of the Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program.” /8 This rulemaking was required inside a yr of enactment of BW-12. FEMA printed an Superior Discover of Proposed Rulemaking to revise the compensation construction of the WYOs on July 8, 2019./39 The remark interval closed on September 6, 2019. Till the evaluation is full, it’s troublesome to establish how a lot it really prices WYO corporations to manage the NFIP insurance policies, or the WYO’s revenue margins (if any).
Within the a hundred and fifteenth Congress, H.R. 2874 would have capped the allowance paid to the WYOs at 27.9% of premiums, whereas S. 1368 would have capped the allowance at 22.46%.
Within the 116th Congress, Part 302 of S. 2187 would have established that the entire quantity of reimbursement paid to WYO corporations couldn’t be higher than 22.46% of the combination quantity of premiums charged by the corporate. This part would even have required FEMA to make sure that the fee paid by a WYO firm to brokers of the corporate wouldn’t be lower than 15%. Part 304 of S. 2187 would require FEMA, inside 12 months of enactment, to develop a schedule to find out the precise prices of WYO corporations and reimburse the WYO corporations just for the precise prices of the service or merchandise. It will have required that every one reimbursements made to WYO corporations be made public, together with an outline of the services or products offered to which the reimbursement pertains. Part 405 of S. 2187 would have required FEMA to determine penalties for underpayment of claims by WYO corporations that aren’t lower than the penalty for overpayment of a declare. Each H.R. 3872 and S. 2187 contained provisions giving FEMA the authority to terminate a WYO contract underneath sure circumstances, reminiscent of fraud or different conduct detrimental to the NFIP.
* * *
34 See primarily 42 U.S.C. Sec.4081 and Sec.4018, and 44 C.F.R. Half 62.
35 The present Direct Servicing Agent is an organization known as Nationwide Flood Providers., who was awarded the contract in October 2020. See https://nationalfloodservices.com/press/nfs-awarded-nfip-direct-service-provider-contract/https://content material.govdelivery.com/accounts/USDHSFEMA/bulletins/1c9da05.
36 Extreme repetitive loss properties are people who have incurred 4 or extra declare funds exceeding $5,000 every, with a cumulative quantity of such funds over $20,000; or a minimum of two claims with a cumulative complete exceeding the worth of the property. See 42 U.S.C. Sec.4014(h) and 44 C.F.R. Sec.79.2(h).
37 E-mail correspondence from FEMA Congressional Affairs employees, March 1, 2019. A listing of corporations collaborating within the WYO program is on the market at https://nfipservices.floodsmart.gov/wyo-program-list.
38 Sec.100224 of P.L. 112-141, 126 Stat. 936.
39 Federal Emergency Administration Company, “Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program (NFIP); Revisions to Methodology for Funds to Write Your Personal (WYO) Firms,” 84(130) Federal Register 32,371-32,379, July 8, 2019, and Federal Emergency Administration Company, “Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program (NFIP); Revisions to Methodology for Funds to Write Your Personal (WYO) Firms; Correction,” 84(170) Federal Register 45,933-45,934, September 3, 2019.
* * *
Reinsurance
Within the House owner Flood Insurance coverage Affordability Act of 2014 (P.L. 113-89, HFIAA), Congress revised the authority of FEMA to safe reinsurance/40 for the NFIP from the non-public reinsurance and capital markets./41 The acquisition of personal market reinsurance reduces the probability of FEMA needing to borrow from the Treasury to pay claims. As well as, because the U.S. Authorities Accountability Workplace (GAO) famous, reinsurance may very well be helpful as a result of it permits FEMA to cost a few of its flood danger up entrance by the premiums it pays to the reinsurers moderately than borrowing from Treasury after a flood./42 From a danger administration perspective, utilizing reinsurance to cowl losses in solely the extra excessive years might assist the federal government to handle and cut back the volatility of its losses over time.
Switch of danger to the non-public sector by reinsurance, nevertheless, is unlikely to decrease the general value of the NFIP as a result of reinsurers understandably cost FEMA premiums to compensate for the chance they assume. The first good thing about reinsurance is to switch and handle danger moderately than to cut back the NFIP’s long-term fiscal publicity./43 For instance, a reinsurance situation which would supply the NFIP with $16.8 billion protection (adequate for Katrina-level losses) might value an estimated $2.2 billion per yr./44 Such a reinsurance premium, nevertheless, can be a big portion of the entire premiums paid into the NFIP, roughly two-thirds of the present premium quantities. Devoting such a big portion of premiums to reinsurance might depart inadequate funds for paying claims exterior of enormous disasters,/45 or for masking the opposite functions for NFIP funds, reminiscent of flood mitigation, mapping, and bettering NFIP ranking buildings.
Reinsurance has been bought by FEMA by two totally different mechanisms, “conventional” reinsurance and reinsurance backed by disaster bonds./46 The normal reinsurance has been bought from a diversified group of reinsurance corporations with every reinsurer bearing a part of the chance. The disaster bond reinsurance is facilitated by a single firm, with the chance then transferred to capital market buyers who buy the bonds. The specifics of every reinsurance buy has diversified, however normally, the reinsurance has been designed to pay a sure proportion of the losses from a single, giant scale occasion, with a better proportion if losses are increased./47 Protection has usually began after $4 billion in losses, a loss stage that has solely been reached by the NFIP in three occasions – Hurricane Katrina, Superstorm Sandy, and Hurricane Harvey. Desk 1 outlines the assorted reinsurance purchases, together with the dates in pressure, sort of reinsurance, quantity of protection, premiums paid by FEMA, and claims paid to FEMA.
* * *
40 Reinsurance is outlined as a transaction between a main insurer and one other licensed (re)insurer the place the reinsurer agrees to cowl all or a part of the losses and/or loss adjustment bills of the first insurer. See NAIC, Glossary of Insurance coverage Phrases, http://www.naic.org/consumer_glossary.htm#R.
41 See Sec.10 of P.L. 113-89, 128 Stat. 1025, as codified at 42 U.S.C. Sec.4081(e).
42 GAO, Flood Insurance coverage: Complete Reform Might Enhance Solvency and Improve Resilience, GAO-17-425, April 2017, p. 19, https://www.gao.gov/merchandise/GAO-17-425.
43 Ibid.
44 FEMA, Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program Report back to Congress on Reinsuring NFIP Insurance coverage Threat and Choices for Privatizing the NFIP, August 13, 2015, p. 171.
45 The NFIP reinsurance purchases have been designed to cowl claims for just one giant flood, and smaller flood claims will proceed to be paid from NFIP premiums.
46 For extra particulars see FEMA, Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program (NFIP) Reinsurance Program, https://www.fema.gov/flood-insurance/work-with-nfip/reinsurance and CRS Perception IN10965, The Nationwide Flood Insurance coverage Program (NFIP), Reinsurance, and Disaster Bonds, by Diane P. Horn and Baird Webel.
47 For instance, the 2020 conventional reinsurance buy lined 10.25% of NFIP losses from $4 billion to $6 billion, 34.68% of losses from $6 billion to $8 billion, and $21.80% of losses from $8 billion to $10 billion.
* * *
Within the a hundred and fifteenth Congress, H.R. 2874, S. 1313, and S. 1571 all contained provisions that will have required or inspired the NFIP to switch a portion of its danger to the non-public reinsurance market. Within the 116th Congress, H.R. 3167, Part 406, would have required FEMA yearly to guage ceding a portion of the chance of the NFIP to the non-public reinsurance or capital markets, if the Administrator determines that the charges and phrases are affordable and doing so would additional the event and upkeep of a sound monetary framework for the NFIP. The Senate invoice within the 116th Congress, S. 2187, didn’t comprise any provisions associated to reinsurance. Within the 117th Congress, companion payments S. 3128 and H.R. 5802 didn’t comprise any provisions associated to reinsurance.
* * *
Desk 1. NFIP Reinsurance Purchases
Supply: FEMA web sites at https://www.fema.gov/flood-insurance/work-with-nfip/reinsurance and data offered by FEMA Congressional Affairs employees, November 15, 2021.
a. Premiums of $62 million in every of first and second years, $63.75 million in third yr.
b. Premiums of $32 million in first yr, $38 million in second yr, $37.2 million in third yr.
c. Premiums of $50.28 million in first yr and $50.88 million in second yr.
d. Premium of $79.44 million within the first yr.
* * *
The NFIP has claimed on reinsurance as soon as, after the losses skilled after Hurricane Harvey, which resulted in over $9 billion paid by the NFIP to policyholders and triggered the complete declare of $1.042 billion on the 2017 reinsurance. So far, FEMA has not claimed on any of the disaster bonds.
* * *
Continues with Half 2 of two
* * *
The report is posted at: https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/R/R45242
