Surety Financial institution finds area of interest serving shoppers that different banks shun

When Ryan James took the reins as CEO of Surety Financial institution, a small group financial institution in DeLand, in 2009, he deliberate to concentrate on advertising and marketing and development.

The Nice Recession upended all that. Regulators charged off 20% of the financial institution’s capital due to what it stated had been dangerous loans. What adopted was a three-year tussle between federal regulators and James, then 30 years outdated and the youngest financial institution CEO in Florida. James says he tried to work along with his prospects to restructure loans, however the regulators appeared intent on having him foreclose on properties to get the loans off the books.

“Each six months,” James says, the regulators got here to the financial institution “reviewing the identical loans over and over for like three years whereas we had been beneath a consent order.”

By 2012, the monetary storm had handed, however James determined that Surety wanted to diversify its portfolio past industrial lending and certificates of deposit.

Virtually perversely given his expertise with the feds, he determined to discover a distinct segment in offering banking companies to a sector of corporations that was beneath heavy regulatory scrutiny: Socalled cash companies companies, resembling check-cashing corporations and payday lenders.

On the time, these cash companies corporations confronted scrutiny for 2 fundamental causes: Some had been accused of exploiting prospects with their enterprise practices. Regulators additionally had been involved they had been at greater danger of being utilized in cash laundering and terrorist actions.

In 2013, the U.S. Division of Justice launched Operation Choke Level geared toward combating client fraud amongst cash companies corporations by “choking out” entry to banking and cost processing companies by fraudulent companies. Payday lenders, nevertheless, noticed a unique motive, claiming in lawsuits that the federal authorities was merely making an attempt to close down an business that wasn’t in political favor — regardless whether or not particular person companies had damaged the legislation or not.

Regardless of the potential for regulatory friction, James noticed alternative. Most banks, relatively than adopting compliance packages to observe potential issues, had merely stopped doing enterprise with the cash companies corporations.

James says he sympathized with the cash companies corporations — “as a result of they had been being handled the way in which I used to be” by the FDIC. He arrange a particular division inside Surety Financial institution to underwrite, monitor and supply banking companies to the business. He says he received some pushback from regulators, who “simply stored throwing out new hurdles. We had been doing greater than the laws acknowledged, however then they might wish to add on to it.”

Initially, Surety labored simply with native check-cashing corporations, however because the financial institution discovered extra about its prospects and tips on how to deal with operational dangers, it expanded its companies throughout Florida and finally to different elements of the nation.

Table of Contents

Observe developments affecting the native economic system

Subscribe to our free Enterprise by the Bay publication

We’ll break down the most recent enterprise and client information and insights it’s essential know each Wednesday.

You’re all signed up!

Need extra of our free, weekly newsletters in your inbox? Let’s get began.

Discover all of your choices

Having discovered a worthwhile area of interest, James led the financial institution into offering companies to different hard-to-serve industries, together with medical marijuana corporations and crypto companies, resembling bitcoin ATM operators.

Within the case of the hashish companies, banks have been reluctant to work with marijuana corporations as a result of promoting hashish stays unlawful beneath federal legislation.

Whereas most banks keep away from banking with marijuana corporations as a result of they’re afraid of reprisals from banking regulators, James says he isn’t frightened. For one, no governmental businesses are literally imposing the “antiquated” federal legal guidelines. Past that, Surety has cobbled collectively its personal set of finest practices to grapple with the conflicting authorized panorama. “The Florida Workplace of Monetary Regulation has fairly stringent cash companies laws, so we use this as a baseline after which add further state or federal legal guidelines to our minimal requirements,” James says.

Cryptocurrency-related companies have confronted related hurdles in establishing banking relationships. One bitcoin ATM operator instructed Florida Pattern that it went to 460 banks earlier than it discovered an establishment prepared to let it open a checking account. Throughout the agency’s early days, staff typically hauled round $200,000 value of money in rubbish luggage.

James says cash companies companies endure a stringent utility course of earlier than Surety will take them on — and transparency is a should. On the finish of the day, he says many of the compliance comes right down to understanding his prospects, waiting for uncommon exercise and having software program and procedures in place to vet transactions.

James says he’d prefer to see extra stringent compliance requirements within the cryptocurrency business. To that finish, he’s a founding member of the Cryptocurrency Compliance Cooperative, a Washington, D.C.-based group that goals to determine common requirements and finest practices to manage the “cash-to-cryptocurrency” business.

Bitcoin ATMs — there are 42,000 throughout the nation — have turn out to be a sexy possibility for criminals to launder cash from drug trafficking and different illicit actions, with some crypto machine operators permitting transactions with customers who present nothing greater than their telephone numbers.

Bolstering requirements will assist root out dangerous actors, legitimize the business and provides banks the instruments they should make sure the digital forex is secure for buyers and companies, James says. He believes regulators will create laws, “they usually’re going to push that accountability down on in the end banks and the exchanges to do the suitable factor to observe,” he says. Surety, he believes, could have a bonus by having already developed methodologies to observe transactions.

Regulatory uncertainties however, the brand new strains of enterprise have been good for Surety Financial institution’s backside line. It ranked second amongst Florida’s 98 banks and thrifts as of the top of the third quarter of 2021 with a 2.68 p.c return on common belongings — a key indicator of financial institution profitability — and James says it has helped the group financial institution develop its buyer base past Central Florida. “We have a look at these industries as our communities. We’re not sure by geography. We’ve got a nationwide group.”

Surety makes its cash off compliance and transaction charges, which fluctuate. “For hashish, we cost a month-to-month compliance price and cashhanding charges that float with quantity. For the crypto business, we cost a proportion of quantity, as this correlates to elevated compliance and monitoring,” James says. “We actually maintain our charges cheap as we don’t really feel it’s proper to benefit from the present local weather.”

The financial institution additionally offers loans to all three industries (crypto, hashish and cash companies corporations), principally for tools and dealing capital.

Whether or not Surety can keep its edge as legal guidelines evolve is an open query. The Safe and Truthful Enforcement Banking Act — which might prohibit penalizing banks that do enterprise with marijuana corporations — has handed the U.S. Home of Representatives 5 occasions, most just lately as an modification to the 2022 protection spending invoice, solely to be scuttled by the Senate.

If it passes, James predicts it should open the floodgates to plenty of competitors. “You will note all main cost networks, megabanks, and so on. swooping in and performing like they had been serving to all alongside,” he says.

• • •

The Financial institution:

SURETY BANK, DeLand

BRANCHES: Lake Mary, Pierson and DeLand

SIZE: 82nd largest financial institution in Florida

HISTORY: Surety was based in 1926 as a constructing and mortgage. Lore has it that the financial institution survived the Nice Despair with barely $2,000 in its vault. Surety additionally survived the financial savings and mortgage disaster within the late Eighties that resulted in collapse of greater than 3,000 thrifts throughout the nation. James says Surety was the one constructing and mortgage that survived in Florida, and on the suggestion of regulators modified its constitution “from a constructing and mortgage to a financial institution.”

TECH TRANSITION: Lately, banks can lose cash on free client checking accounts, says James. A part of the issue, he says, are the charges that many financial institution system software program suppliers cost banks for must-have companies resembling on-line banking, invoice paying and cell banking. To resolve the issue, he ditched the financial institution’s legacy software program supplier and went with Jacksonville-based startup Nymbus, which transitioned Surety to a personal cloud-based software program and supplied larger flexibility in companies and pricing.

FILLING A VOID: When BB&T shuttered its department in Pierson (inhabitants 1,913) in 2019, city officers scrambled to seek out one other financial institution to take its place. Surety Financial institution answered the decision. “Lots of people in the neighborhood want to have the ability to money their checks on Friday. They had been actually appreciative,” James says. “Quite a lot of our transactions occur at that little department.”

• • •

The BANKER

Ryan James, 42 President /CEO, SURETY BANK, DeLand

EDUCATION: Bachelor’s diploma in finance and actual property from Florida State College in 2001

GROWING UP: James’ household labored within the fern business in Pierson in Volusia County, and he spent his summers digging irrigation ditches, sustaining diesel engines and clearing land. “You understand the fern in rose preparations, the darkish inexperienced fern? That’s both grown right here (in Volusia County) or Costa Rica — these are the one two locations on this planet,” James says.

EXPERIENCE: James had deliberate on a profession as a stockbroker, however an internship at inventory brokerage agency soured him on the occupation. On the suggestion of his father, a shareholder and director of Surety Financial institution, he determined to attempt banking. Shortly after he began, the financial institution’s CFO had a coronary heart assault, and James was thrown into the position. “It was trial by fireplace, proper then and there,” he says.

GENERATION GAP: When James was promoted to CEO of Surety Financial institution in 2009 at 30, he was the youngest financial institution CEO in Florida. After 12 years, he says he nonetheless “stands proud” at banking conferences. He says the old-guard banking executives are inclined to “complain about the identical issues they’ve for the final 20 years” — laws and credit score unions. “I don’t have time to concentrate on them,” James says. “I’ve to do what we do finest.”