Press play to hearken to this text
Nothing grabs politicians’ consideration sooner than offended voters, they usually’ve had a lot to be livid about as pure fuel and electrical energy payments have soared to stomach-churning ranges in current months.
That is led to a scramble to determine methods to get these prices down — however that is turning out to be very tough, so the likeliest result’s that EU leaders assembly later this week will not give you any options.
“There is no such thing as a single straightforward reply to deal with the excessive electrical energy costs given the range of conditions amongst Member States. Some choices are solely appropriate for particular nationwide contexts,” the European Fee mentioned on Wednesday. “All of them carry prices and disadvantages.”
The preliminary downside was a surge in fuel demand in Asia final yr coupled with lower-than-normal Russian fuel deliveries that left European fuel storage at unusually low ranges. Now the warfare in Ukraine is making issues even worse, as stress grows for the bloc to quickly reduce its imports of Russian oil, coal and pure fuel — though some nationwide leaders reject the financial prices that might entail.
“We’ll finish this dependence as shortly as we are able to, however to try this from sooner or later to the subsequent would imply plunging our nation and all of Europe right into a recession,” German Chancellor Olaf Scholz warned on Wednesday.
The issue for the bloc is that its liberalized electrical energy market is tightly tied to the value of pure fuel; energy costs are set by the ultimate enter wanted to steadiness demand — known as pay-as-clear — which generally is ready by pure fuel. That is led to nations with giant quantities of cheaper renewable or nuclear vitality seeing sharp spikes in energy costs because of the price of that closing little bit of gas-fired electrical energy.
A Spanish-led coalition that features Portugal, Belgium and Italy desires deep reforms to the EU value mannequin.
Others, such because the Netherlands and Germany, strongly oppose such an method and need to deal with cushioning the consequences of the excessive costs on customers and companies, whereas letting the market function.
A 3rd group, largely in Central Europe, desires to make use of the value spike to revamp or scrap the bloc’s Emissions Buying and selling System and to rethink its Match for 55 local weather laws.
The European Fee has been holding the center floor — arguing that the present market mannequin is smart, however encouraging nations to spice up the quantity of renewable electrical energy, to chop vitality use and enhance effectivity.
In draft conclusions of this week’s European Council summit, seen by POLITICO, EU leaders name for issues like a standard method to purchasing fuel, aimed toward stopping nations from competing in opposition to one another. However there isn’t any large motion on electrical energy costs.
“It doesn’t appear life like to count on a end result on the vitality dialogue at this European Council,” one diplomat mentioned, stressing that the governments might want to see extra evaluation earlier than committing to any extra steps.
Searching for motion
Spain wished a way more sturdy response. Madrid has been arguing since final summer season for “decoupling” fuel from the electrical energy market; along with Portugal, it additionally mulled limiting the wholesale value of electrical energy to €180 per megawatt-hour — a proposal that Spain deserted beneath fireplace from trade and shopper teams.
Now Madrid is pushing to get a particular permission within the summit’s closing conclusions that might enable nations to voluntarily apply sure short-term options comparable to value caps, in accordance with a draft with monitor modifications seen by POLITICO.
The difficulty with a cap is that if fuel costs are larger than the cap, Spain may not be capable to purchase any fuel.
Value caps — both on the electrical energy or fuel market — are “not choice,” mentioned Natalia Collado Van-Baumberghen, a analysis economist at Spain’s EsadeEcPol assume tank.
“Should you impose a value cap [on the gas market], how are you going to draw extra LNG cargoes to Europe?” she mentioned. “When there is a peak of demand for fuel … Asia is ready to pay extra for that fuel, clearly the cargoes go to Asia.”
Spain’s concepts have been picked up by different leaders.
”We’ve got mentioned the significance of decoupling, a separation between fuel and electrical energy. We mentioned the potential for having a managed value within the fuel market,” Italian Prime Minister Mario Draghi mentioned after assembly together with his Spanish, Portuguese and Greek counterparts final week. “We’ve got related concepts. However we have now to persuade different member states, states which have totally different wants and really totally different buildings and infrastructures,” he added.
Belgian Prime Minister Alexander De Croo has additionally come out with the proposal to set a brief value cap on wholesale costs in European fuel markets at €120 per megawatt-hour.
The Fee mentioned it might have a look at choices to “optimize” the EU’s electrical energy market by Might. First, it desires to investigate the outcomes of an upcoming report from the European Union Company for the Cooperation of Power Regulators.
Brussels is open to nations intervening instantly within the wholesale electrical energy market by value caps or compensating fossil-based electrical energy mills. However such steps entail potential drawbacks — value, distortion of competitors, dangers to cross-border commerce and safety of electrical energy provide.
Exterior specialists and different EU governments are additionally cautious of such a excessive stage of intervention.
“Fairly frankly, there will be no undermining of market mechanisms or everlasting subsidies, particularly on fossil vitality,” Scholz mentioned on Wednesday.
There’s additionally fear that decoupling fuel from the electrical energy market would take away an incentive to spend money on renewable vitality — one of many cornerstones of the European Inexperienced Deal and in addition tied to the EU’s plan to drop Russian fossil fuels.
The electrical energy market was designed to be “the very best mate” of renewable vitality mills, mentioned Collado Van-Baumberghen. “We should not change the market as a result of [it’s] essentially the most environment friendly strategy to go to our objective of 100% of renewable era.”
That is fairly skinny gruel to nationwide leaders beneath fireplace at residence.
“This can be a fuel disaster. This isn’t an electrical energy disaster,” mentioned Tim Schittekatte, postdoctoral affiliate on the MIT Power Initiative. “Within the short-term electrical energy market, it does precisely what you count on it to do … that is nothing flawed. What doesn’t imply that the impression on the ultimate shopper payments and trade payments is just not one thing to fret about.”
Paola Tamma, Camille Gijs and Hannah Roberts contributed reporting.
This text is a part of POLITICO Professional
The one-stop-shop resolution for coverage professionals fusing the depth of POLITICO journalism with the facility of know-how
Unique, breaking scoops and insights
Personalized coverage intelligence platform
A high-level public affairs community
